Reflection
Samantha Horrocks
HIST 1700
Summer Semester 2024
Reflection
Reflect back to the Big Picture Essay you just submitted for Module 14. What were the strengths of your submission? If you were to do this again, how might you improve?
Reflecting back on the Big Picture Essay submitted for Module 14, it is evident that it has strengths and improvement areas.
The argument presented is well-backed by evidence and logical reasoning. It draws upon instances from time periods, such as McCarthyism in the Cold War era and the implementation of the Patriot Act post-9/11, to demonstrate the recurring trend of sacrificing freedoms for security reasons. These examples emphasize the balance societies need to strike between preserving liberties and addressing security threats. This ongoing debate continues to shape policy decisions and public opinion in our modern world.
Analytical Insights: The essay analyzes how these government actions impact liberties and society at large. It sheds light on the repercussions of measures and their lasting effects on democracy. Furthermore, it explores how public sentiment can shape policy decisions and the delicate balance between security and freedom.
Thesis Statement: To effectively guide the reader through the argument, it would be helpful to make the thesis statement more straightforward and place it at the beginning of the essay. A concise and explicit thesis can set the stage for a discussion. For example, revising it to outline arguments and their sequence can help readers follow the flow of ideas and grasp the essay's message. Moreover, well-placed topic sentences can further delineate the structure and ensure that each paragraph contributes cohesively to the overarching argument.
Source Integration: Though various sources are mentioned in the essay, a seamless integration of these references into the narrative is recommended. Rather than listing sources, incorporating them into the argument with detailed citations would enhance academic credibility. It is also essential to ensure that these sources are up-to-date and relevant to strengthen research quality and show an understanding of the topic. Moreover, acknowledging opposing viewpoints and addressing potential counterarguments can further demonstrate a well-rounded and critical approach to the analysis.
Counterarguments: Including discussions on counterarguments or different viewpoints could deepen the essay's analysis. Addressing opposing views that argue that measures are necessary for security, followed by refutations, would present a more balanced perspective. Supporting these arguments with examples or data can further enhance critical analysis. Moreover, taking into account the ethical aspects and potential long-term implications of these surveillance practices can lead to an understanding of the issue.
In conclusion, it is essential to strengthen the conclusion for an ending. Summarizing the points and emphasizing the importance of preserving liberties, especially during challenging times, can leave a lasting impression on the reader. Encouraging exploration and ongoing discussions on these subjects can also drive significant policy changes. Ultimately, we must remain vigilant in protecting our freedoms while fostering an environment of conversations and proactive involvement.
If I were to rewrite the essay, there are some things that I would like to improve on:
Enhance Structure and Clarity: Begin with a thesis statement. Organize the essay into distinct sections with subheadings to ensure smooth transitions between each part.
Strengthen Arguments: Provide concrete evidence and examples to support each point presented.
Edit and Proofread: Meticulously review the essay for grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, and overall coherence to enhance the final presentation.
Vary Sentence Structure: Incorporate a mix of short, impactful sentences and longer, more complex ones to maintain reader engagement and improve the overall flow of the essay.
Improve Source Integration: Utilize sources by seamlessly incorporating them into the argument with detailed citations. This involves paraphrasing content frequently and using direct quotes sparingly but strategically.
Address Counterarguments: Acknowledge and rebut counterarguments to present a rounded perspective, demonstrating an appreciation for differing viewpoints while reinforcing my stance.
Craft an ending; Make sure the conclusion effectively recaps the ideas and emphasizes the significance of the essay's thesis. Discuss the impact of the discoveries. Propose remedies or future explorations. By concluding with thoughts, I provide readers with closure and a thorough grasp of my viewpoint. To sum up, by tackling these aspects and providing suggestions, you showcase the importance of my examination and enrich dialogues within the domain.